Didn't fully pass my fussy cat's test
I thought the sticks looked ok, no nasty smells and a decent meaty consistency, unlike some of the cheap imitation ones you can get now.
Weirdly, my cat seemed to plough through about 2/3rds of the stick and then leave the rest... I'm not really sure why! She's usually an all or nothing type with meat sticks. As with many things with cats, great if your cat isn't too fussy and takes to them. Didn't pass our fluffy girl's test! I received the product for free, in return for honest feedback.