Paste
My dogs love this. It’s a paste so sticks to the dry biscuits so better toilet results etc. they always finish the bowl even to the point of licking it out of the bowl holder.
I can always tell if it’s good by how close my girl gets to me when making her food. She stands behind me sniffing the oxygen out of the air when I open these tins.
My dogs have major reaction issues to food. She will literally destroy herself scratching if it’s not right. Thankfully after a long search, we got it right